
Selling off market in Sydney: What it really means and to get the best result
There's a certain excitement that comes with a 'Sold Off Market' sign outside a beautiful home in one of Sydney’s premier suburbs, signifying some lucky new owners who managed to nab the perfect property before anyone else got wind of the sale.
It’s a compelling story, but it’s based on a form of industry-speak that we feel is long overdue for retirement.
At DiJones, we don’t use the phrase “off market”. We don’t train our agents on it, as we find it somewhat misleading. Our view is simple: if a property is being sold, it’s on the market. There’s no off switch.
What people call an off-market sale is really just a sale with a narrower audience — and whether that is the right approach for your home is more of a question about strategy rather than whether your home is or isn’t ‘on the market’.
Unfortunately, the term has become entrenched in the language of our industry, and we know it isn’t likely to be leaving anytime soon. Sellers search for it, buyers ask about it, and agents across Sydney use it regularly. So if you’ve come looking for an article about whether selling off market is right for your property, this article is still for you. But we’d like to remove some of the haze and take a more straightforward approach to the question.
Off market vs pre-market
First, it’s important to understand the difference between off- and pre-market sales. A fully off-market property will not be listed publicly at all. There will be no overt advertising campaign and no option to go to auction. Once you give an agent your listing, they will contact potential buyers that they have matched to your property. Viewings will be exclusive, protecting your valued privacy, and only qualified, ready-to-go buyers will be brought in. In contrast, a pre-market strategy will involve a short hush-hush period before the listing appears publicly with a full marketing campaign. Potential buyers will be notified that your property is going to come onto the market in the near future and will be given the opportunity to make an offer before it does. If your home doesn’t sell in the stipulated time, the marketing campaign will kick off and your property will be officially on the market.
Where the term “off market” actually came from
For a long time, most agents treated the major portals, such as realestate.com.au and Domain, as though they were the market. If a property was listed there, it was on the market. If it wasn't, it was off. And so the language followed the logic.
In our experience, what agents originally meant by “off market” was closer to “off portal”. A property sold outside these portals was still absolutely for sale, just not in the place everyone referred to as the market.
That distinction is more of a reflection of the fact that many agents didn’t have much faith in their own website, their social channels, or their database of local buyers as genuine ways to reach a sale. That may still be the case for some, but we’ve worked tirelessly over the years to ensure that DiJones agents aren’t wholly reliant on the major portals in order to achieve a great result.
The marketplaces your home can sell through
Today, properties can be sold through a number of well-established and fruitful marketplaces:
- The major portals – still the largest audience, and where most buyers begin their search.
- An agency’s own website – having an established brand with a strong local readership is now a significant source of qualified buyers.
- Social media – an increasingly powerful tool for reaching buyers who will move quickly for the right property.
- An agent’s database – the buyers an agent already knows, has already qualified, and has already matched to a brief.
- Buyers’ agent relationships – intermediaries representing serious buyers, many of them expats, interstate, or time-poor.
A good sales strategy takes stock of all of these options. Full campaigns might use all of them, small campaigns might use fewer. But no sale uses none of them, which is precisely the point we’re making:
The difference between one campaign and another isn’t on versus off market. It’s which marketplaces your agent is using, and whether they’ve chosen them deliberately or by default.
Off market vs pre-market
Two terms you’ll hear a lot are “off market” and “pre-market”. Although they’re used interchangeably, they mean different things, and both are better understood as different points in the sales process rather than as totally separate products.
What people call a fully off market sale is a campaign with the narrowest audience. There's no portal listing and no public advertising, and typically no auction. Instead, your agent works their database directly, approaching the buyers they believe are a genuine match and bringing them through privately. It’s a small and controlled audience, but your property is still very much for sale and is therefore on the market.
On the other hand, a pre-market campaign expands in stages. Buyers are told a property is coming, and given the chance to make an offer before the full campaign begins. If it doesn’t sell in that window, the marketing rolls out and the audience widens to everyone.
What separates the two is how wide the net is cast and for how long. But how well either one works comes down to your agent: the strength of their database, how they manage buyers and underbidders, and how well connected they are to the local market. Both are legitimate approaches for the right property, in the right hands.
This leads us to the strategy question that sellers should really be asking…
A better question: how are you selling my home for the best result?
When a seller asks us whether they should sell off market, what they're usually really asking is: how do I get the best possible result for my home?
Now that is a question worth answering. And answering it properly means talking less about visibility toggling and more about strategy.
A genuine sales strategy should tell you, clearly and specifically:
- Who the likely buyer is:
A genuine profile that goes deeper than “someone looking in the area”. - Which marketplaces reach them:
Making a deliberate choice on whether to use portals, website, social, database, or buyers’ agents is easier once you know who you’re targeting. - How competition will be created:
Competition for the property and the eventual sale price are closely linked. A good sales strategy needs to plan for generating buyer competition. - What the campaign actually looks like:
Timing, pricing approach, method of sale, what marketing material is needed, and how long each stage should take. - What happens if it doesn’t go to plan:
The best agents already have a plan for the next move before the first one is made.
Notice that none of this hinges on whether the property is described as on or off market. A discreet, database-led campaign can be a genuinely strong strategy for the right property. This is particularly true where privacy matters, or where an agent has a qualified buyer who is an obvious match. What makes it a strategy is that it was chosen for a reason, and the reason can be explained.
The problem with "off market" as a term is that it lets an agent skip that explanation entirely. It sounds like a plan without ever having to be one.
This is why we find that our conversations with sellers tend to go differently. Vendors come to us having been offered "off market access" by another agent or a buyers' agent, and they're often surprised to find we don't talk about it that way at all. What we talk about instead is what we're going to do, why we're going to do it, and what result we expect it to produce. Once a seller has seen an actual strategy laid out, the question of whether their home is technically on or off the market tends to stop mattering.
Why do buyers seek out off market properties?
Buyers like what the industry calls ‘off market’ properties for a few reasons.
The first is the exclusivity appeal. Being part of a small group of handpicked, pre-qualified buyers means they’re up against much less competition. Buyers who have previously tried and failed to secure their ideal home at auction could be willing to pay a premium for the opportunity to buy a home off market.
Another reason is the matchmaking dynamic. When buyers register their interest with an agent, they often provide a detailed brief of what they’re looking for and what they’re willing to pay for it. When a property comes up that ticks those boxes, buyers can be quick to act, potentially leading to a faster sales process.
Let’s take a moment to discuss buyers’ agents in finer detail. Many expats, interstate, and out-of-area buyers can't or won't spend their Saturdays at inspections only to watch a property slip away at auction, so they engage a buyers' agent to find, review, and negotiate on their behalf. Part of the service those agents offer is getting their client in front of a property before anyone else does.
But whose interests does that actually serve?
“We can get you in before anyone else bids” is certainly enticing… for the buyer.
But the vendor’s position works differently. Competition can drive prices, and the more qualified buyers who know your property is available, the stronger your position tends to be. So limiting who hears about a property should be a deliberate choice.
Sometimes, it is legitimately the better option, and we use early-offer strategies ourselves when they suit what a vendor is trying to achieve. In any case, what matters most is how the offer gets handled. A strong early offer should come to you alongside a clear view of what a full campaign might deliver, so you can weigh one against the other. You might take it. You might decide to test the market first. Either way, that call belongs to you, made with the whole picture in front of you.
So when a seller is approached with the promise of a buyer who's ready to move quietly and quickly, the question worth asking is: is this the best result available for my home, or simply the fastest? Sometimes those are the same thing, and a good agent will tell you which one you’re looking at.
Is an off-market sale right for every property?
There’s no such thing as a one-size-fits-all approach to property sales, and a narrow campaign carries some trade-offs.
The first is reduced exposure. A smaller audience means fewer buyers competing, and the competition is what tends to push the price up. Buyers who never knew your home was available can't bid on it.
The second is that a narrow campaign leans more heavily on your agent's database. That database isn’t entirely separate from the portals (as most buyers will have made it into the database via a portal anyway) but it does mean the quality of the agent’s buyer management matters more. How well they’ve tracked who’s looking, what those buyers want, and who’s still in the market after missing out elsewhere. A deep, well-maintained, and active database makes a narrow campaign viable.
Which is the point, really. A narrower campaign isn’t inherently wrong, it just needs to make sense for the property and the vendor. If there’s a good reason and an agent with the reach to deliver, then it can be a great option.
The question you should be asking
The decision about how to sell your home will always be specific to your property, your circumstances, and your market. Some homes genuinely benefit from a targeted, database-led approach. Many more benefit from the competition that comes with a full campaign. The right answer rarely reveals itself until you've had a proper conversation with an agent who knows your area.
But whatever that conversation covers, it shouldn't hinge on whether your home is described as on or off the market. That distinction was never as meaningful as the industry made it sound, and treating it as the central question has cost sellers a lot of potentially fruitful conversations.
The question worth asking your agent is a different one: how are you going to sell my home for the best possible result, and why is that the right approach for this property?
If that question is met with a clear answer, you’re in good hands. If not, keep asking.
At DiJones, that conversation is where we start. Our goal has always been to get the best possible result for your property, and our advice is built around that rather than around industry shorthand. If you would like to talk to our team about what method is best for you, connect with us here.
And for more information about different methods of sale, click here.
Disclaimer
DiJones Real Estate, together with their directors, officers, employees and agents have used their best endeavours to ensure the information passed on in this document is accurate. However, you must make your own enquiries in relation to the information contained in this document and seek advice from your financial advisor, broker or accountant to ascertain its application to your circumstances.
This information is provided subject to our Terms and Conditions.
Was this content helpful to you?






